Does failure really lead to learning and innovation?

Does failure really lead to learning and innovation?

Innovation

Innovation and failure

There is a saying in business about failure. You are going to fail. Many times. So fail fast and learn fast.

The standard rhetoric around failure and organisations encountering problems and disruptions are that it invariably leads to innovative problem-solving and innovation. The question is whether this idea that failure leads to learning and innovation is correct.

There appears to be a plethora of research and organisational lore around the idea of failure and the ‘fail fast’ doctrine in which organisations are prompted to experiment, learn and innovate. In effect, a common narrative has sprung up around the idea that failure is a positive in terms of promoting learning and innovation.

…Innovation is seen as the lifeblood of many organisations

Innovation

Recent studies

A number of more recent studies have shown that failure has very different effects on different organisations. Some research has shown that failure during disruptive and challenging times and when organisations are operating in unfamiliar fields often leads to negative consequences, inappropriate or misguided learning and either reduces innovation or sets organisations off in unhelpful directions that are damaging to the organisation.

More recently, research has started to show that the degree and level of learning from failure varies significantly from organisation to organisation, dependent on a range of factors including the nature and the primary characteristics of that organisation.

What does failure mean?

In terms of innovation, a significant proportion of ideas and innovations do not achieve their goals, purposes, and desired outcomes. The primary definition of failure from a research and organisational perspective is whether or not the performance of an innovation or organisation meets, or is close to, the aspirations held for it.

It is recognised that ‘failure’ is a subjective concept, usually defined from the perspective of an individual or group/team of people. There are, however, more objective definitions of failure, which include outcomes such as bankruptcy, death, and the abandonment of an innovation or project.

Failure

Learning from failure

Whilst there is a lot of research that highlights the central importance of failure for motivating learning and change , there is also considerable counter evidence to show that failure can frequently reduce learning, create significant errors in learning and slowdown, or even stop, change.

Whilst research has shown that the degree of failure (how bad the outcome and effects of the failure are) can have a significant impact on how accurate the learning is from the failure, in that failures that result in considerable levels of loss (including significant levels of loss of status, power and position, as well as financial loss and loss of life) are significantly less likely to result in learning. For example, some studies have found that organisations that suffer from major failures and substantial levels of loss of some description are significantly more likely to attribute external reasons to the failure, rather than internal ones.

Failure in organisation

Loss degree effect or degree of failure effect

However, the ‘loss degree effect’ or ‘degree of failure effect’, as it is known, is far from consistent and other studies have shown that organisations can and do learn from high loss degree effect situations, and go on to create innovation and change that gives the organisation a considerable competitive advantage.

A new study

A new study by researchers from the Korean University Business School and the Korea Small-Business Institute has looked at what organisational factors and characteristics predict learning from failure.

Findings on failure

The study, using new analytical techniques, found that a significant portion of an organisation’s ability to learn from failure is largely down to the internal characteristics of the organisation. The primary organisational characteristics which were found to promote learning from failure,and which promoted appropriate change and innovation are:

Failure experience

Previous experiences of failure. The study found that organisations that were used to experiencing failure, and where those experiences resulted in learning within the organisation, were significantly more likely to learn and innovate positive change. Organisations with little experience of failure, or organisations who routinely hid or ignored failure, were significantly less likely to learn and create appropriate change and innovation.

Organisational search behaviours

Organisational search behaviours. The study found that organisations that were engaged in open innovation (or continually and habitually looking at their own and other sectors for ideas) were significantly more likely to create appropriate learning change and innovation following a significant failure. The study also found that the breadth and depth of organisational search behaviours matters.

Absorptive capacity

Absorptive capacity: The level of an organisation’s absorptive capacity (an organisation’s ability to identify, assimilate, transform and use/integrate external knowledge, research and practice) was also found to be a significant predictor of failure-based learning.

Innovation implementation

Innovation implementation: Organisations that are used to and have experience in implementing organisational innovation (have effective levels of organisational ambidexterity) were significantly associated with higher levels of learning from failure effectiveness.

Innovation implementation

Organisational search behaviours

Lastly, the study found that organisational search behaviours are only a significant predictive factor for learning from failure when there are high levels of internal collaboration across the organisation and good knowledge management practices.

Reference

Nami Kim &Jongseon Lee (2020): Who is leaping through failure? The influence of innovation characteristics on learning from failure, Industry and Innovation, DOI: 10.1080/13662716.2020.1751088

Innovation capacity: how to develop it in your organisation

 

Disclaimer: This is a research review, expert interpretation and briefing. As such it contains other studies, expert comment and practitioner advice. It is not a copy of the original study – which is referenced. The original study should be consulted and referenced in all cases. This research briefing is for informational and educational purposes only. We do not accept any liability for the use to which this review and briefing is put or for it or the research accuracy, reliability or validity. This briefing as an original work in its own right and is copyright © Oxcognita LLC 2016-2019. Any use made of this briefing is entirely at your own risk.

Be impressively well informed

Get the very latest research intelligence briefings, video research briefings, infographics and more sent direct to you as they are published

Be the most impressively well-informed and up-to-date person around...

Powered by ConvertKit
Like what you see? Help us spread the word

Kafilat

  • […]      ← Previous post […]

  • >