The Oxford Review Volume 4 No 1 | The Oxford Review - OR Briefings

The Oxford Review Volume 4 No 1

The Oxford Review Vol 4 No 1

This month we have research that answers a series of key questions:

Do Long Term Incentive Plans for pay actually incentivise anything?

Keywords: Long Term Incentive Plans, pay, remuneration, reward, CEO pay incentives, CEO incentives
Long Term Incentive Plans have been part of organisational thinking for a long time. In 1970 approximately 7% of organisations had some form of Long Term Incentive Plan, by 1985 this had grown to approximately 40%of organisations and by 2017 approximately 54% of organisations had some form of Long Term Incentive Plan for executives.
The idea behind a Long Term Incentive Plan is to reward senior management for achieving earning goals (usually) typically over a 4-5 year period. Long Term Incentive Plansare used in combination with more traditional stock or share options to ‘connect’ the executive to the company and ensure they have some ‘skin in the game’.
Logically, many see the appeal of having some form of Long Term Incentive Plan to motivate senior managers to:
  1. Be attracted to and stay with the company long term.
  2. Deliver superior performance, usually in terms of earnings or other financial performance such as share price.
  3. Align the interests of the executive team with those of the shareholders or owners of the company.
It is estimated that approximately a third of executives’ total earnings come from Long Term Incentive Plans. However more recent research has severely questioned whether LTIP’s actually do promote better organisational and senior management performance.
This research briefing is essential reading for anyone interested in the effectiveness of reward in general and Long Term Incentive Plans in particular.

Just how morally and ethically acceptable is executive and developmental coaching?

Keywords: coaching, executive coaching, developmental coaching, ethics, morality
A small but growing number of thinkers and researchers have been challenging the ethics and morality of developmental and executive style coaching. Whilst
to many developmental and executive coaching can only be a force for good, significant disquiet is growing about the activities that such coaching necessarily entails.
Part of the problem is the complex and paradoxical concept of personal development and what the idea of ‘the self’ is or should be. One of the core axioms of both personal development and development of coaching is that it is essentially a reflective and introspective process, in that it requires the individual to think about one’s self in terms of how that individual is ‘performing’, ‘being’ or behaving. However, this introspection isn’t one of seeking acceptance of who they are and how they behave, rather, it is a process of attempting change and ‘development’. The question is, therefore, change to what and according to whose definition?
This research is essential reading for every organisational and executive coach and coaching supervisor.

The five styles of leadership that can be developed through game-based learning

Keywords: leadership, game-based learning, skills, leadership styles, leadership development
Game-based learning as an approach to developing leadership skills has been attracting a lot of attention from researchers and practitioners alike. Game-based learning uses a variety of different technologies to enhance and deepen learning and has beensuccessfully used in a variety of different fields. However, it has not as yet been widely tested as a method for developing leadership skills.
This research briefing looks at a study that looked to:
  1. Identify which leadership skills could be developed in a game context
  2. Identify whether a training programme using game-based learning could lead to new leadership styles that were relevant in an organisational context.

How external stakeholders impact project management

Keywords: project management, stakeholders, stakeholders, strategic actions, influence, external stakeholders, influencing strategies
A number of studies have shown what most project managers have known for a long time – that external stakeholders can have a significant impact on projects and project management. A 2014 study showed that external stakeholders can also have a significant impact on the entire project environment.
Hitherto, however, only a relatively small amount of research has been conducted looking at the impact and influence external stakeholders have on projects.
This research briefing is essential reading for anyone involved in project management and in particular project managers and leaders.

Increasing employee retention and performance: the case for workplace flourishing

Keywords: workplace flourishing, intention to leave, person-environment fit, employee performance, organisational citizenship behaviours, role performance
Retaining staff, especially highly skilled and productive talent, has become a key issue in many organisations. As a result, a lot of organisational and research interest is focused on two primary areas:
  1. Employee retention
  2. Employee performance
One of the paradoxes within organisations is that the more highly skilled and productive you are the more work and responsibility you tend to get. Many studies and anecdotal evidence from organisations has shown that this cycle of increased productivity leading to having more to do frequently leads to employee stress, burnout and illnesses, such as depression, for example. As a direct result of this issue an increasing emphasis on work-life balance has entered the arena. More recently, attention has moved from the more nebulous search for work-life balance into the idea of flourishing.
This research briefing looks at research about the connections between workplace flourishing and employee retention and performance.


Is the use of strengths as powerful as we might think? What are the factors that matter?

Keywords: Character, signature strengths, well-being, organisational behaviour, trait affect, job satisfaction, job strain
Many organisations today recognise the benefits of leveraging the positive qualities of employees, as well as minimising any problematic areas. Research in the field of positive organisational scholarship suggests this approach is well placed, with positive outcomes being seen from the development of employees’ strengths, maximising positive emotional states, and encouraging flourishing. In particular, the use of signature strengths at work has been associated with a variety of positive outcomes over the long term.
Character strengths
Character strengths can be defined as individual differences in universally recognised and valued positive traits, that are reflected in particular ways of thinking, feeling and behaving. Whilst there is ongoing debate over the number of character strengths, research conducted in 2004 identified 24 universally valued strengths clustered under six higher-level virtues. There is evidence that these 24 strengths apply across cultures. Higher levels of character strengths have been positively linked to pleasure, meaning, and engagement. They are also associated with an enhanced ability to cope with stress. Further research has shown links between specific strengths and outcomes, such as the strength of perseverance and self-reported performance.
This research briefing will be useful for anyone involved in Human Resources, Human Capital and Human Resource Management and anyone interested in the impact using employees signature strengths has in the workplace.

Soft is hard: Building resilience with loving kindness meditation

Keywords: resilience, stress, well-being, mindfulness, loving-kindness meditation, personal development, well-being
In our workplaces today, personal development is seen as key. It is common to hear the adage of ‘no pain, no gain’ and people are given stretch assignments, with the best of intentions, that push them out of their comfort zones. This approach works well for some people who find it stimulating, generating positive stress responses. However, previous studies have found there are also many people who respond negatively in the same situation. Employees who become distressed by the challenges of the workplace often have reduced performance, long-term chronic stress, and negative mental and physical health (e.g. depression, anxiety, headaches, diabetes, ulcers and heart disease). The ability to cope under pressure is important to ensure our well-being and has been linked to resilience.
This research briefing looks at a study about the effectiveness of one type of meditation in developing resilience and will be useful to anyone interested in developing resilience and well-being.

The importance of individuals in teams

Keywords: team, teams, emergent properties, team characteristics, team performance, team success, team development
The importance of teams to many organisations is axiomatic. A 2013 study of 831 companies around the world found that employees on average tend
to spend 54% of their time working within teams. It was found that employees in China spend higher amounts of time than average in teams where employees tend to spend an average of 64.8% of their time in a team setting. The country with the lowest average time spent working in a team is South Africa, where the average is 47%. America had an average of 51.4% of an employee’s time being spent in teams.
A review by researcher has looked at the ‘outlier’ influence of individuals within teams and their ability to influence team processes and outcomes.
The study looked at case-based scenarios where individuals have changed the direction of teams, often by direct challenge and frequently despite considerable levels of animosity and hostility from both within and without the team.
This research briefing is essential reading for anyone involved or interested in team development and leadership.

The problem of presenteeism

Keywords: presenteeism, absenteeism, employee health, risk management, human resources, HR
Whilst most organisations and considerable volumes of research examine and focus on absenteeism, it is starting to be realised that presenteeism has recently been found to be a significant factor to impact organisational performance.
Presenteeism refers to the practice of employees attending or going to work when they are ill. While absenteeism has been shown to account for approximately 4% of productivity losses within organisations, globally there has been no agreed measurement of the impact of presenteeism on productivity. But the problem is that there has been no agreed process for measuring presenteeism.
This research briefing is based on a new (2019) review and meta-analysis of the existing research has looked afresh at the issue of presenteeism in organisations and will be of great interest to managers and Human Resources personnel.

The role of ‘bodily resonance’ in creating implicit bias

Keywords: work psychology, behaviour, bias, cognitive bias, implicit bias, biases, bodily resonance, self-image
One of the more common questions people have about biases, particularly biases towards or against other people, is wheresuch biases come from or how do they start?
Our beliefs about other people and the cultural and social groups to which they belong are central to how we interact with them, trust them, relate with them and build or not build relationships with them.
A number of recent studies in 2009, 2015 and 2017 have found that many of our biases concerning other people actually stem and are based upon physical appearance. Previous studies have suggested (but not shown) that our biases may well be provoked by comparing our own self-image with that of the other person. This is a process known as ‘bodily resonance’.
This research briefing looks at some astounding research results around how to get people to change their biases and beliefs.

Using Fab Labs for strategic knowledge management

Keywords: Fab Labs, knowledge management, strategic knowledge management, digital knowledge management
The central importance of knowledge within organisations is now widely recognised as being a critical success factor. Many studies have shown that strategic information and knowledge are both social, operational and strategic tools which, used correctly, can ensure an organisation’s competitive advantage, survival and success.
This research briefing examines the usefulness of Fab Labs as a strategic knowledge management tool in organisations. This research briefings is essential reading for anyone interested in knowledge management.

Why organisations empower the people and how does it impact the organisation’s performance?

Keywords: employee empowerment, empowerment practices, empowerment, organisational performance, ambiguity, cost, human resources
One of the distinguishing features in terms of management and human resource management of employees has been the steady increase in interest in empowerment practices. The basis of employee empowerment is that employees are given considerable decision-making power, autonomy and accountability.
The argument that sits behind this move is that adopting empowerment practices not only gets the best from people, motivates them and increases engagement, but also improves organisational performance and increases an organisation’s competitive advantage. Empowerment is a central element of many modern high-performance work practices.
However, the research shows mixed results for such practices and the claims that adopting empowerment practices will unilaterally improve organisational performance and increase an organisation’s competitive advantage is false. It may do, then again it may not. Recent studies have shown that organisations that do not embrace empowerment practices are not always significantly disadvantaged when compared with organisations that do.
These mixed results for empowerment practices raise two questions:
  1. Why do organisations adopt empowerment practices?
  2. How does adopting empowerment practices impact organisational performance?
This research briefing looks at a study which answers these questions and will be extremely useful to anyone interested in empowerment in organisations, which organisations tend to adopt empowerment practices and what the impact is of doing so.

Not a member?

Apply to join now and get:


  1. Weekly research briefings sent direct to you every week
  2. A copy of the Oxford Review containing between twelve and sixteen additional research briefings every month
  3. Research Infographics
  4. Video research briefings.
  5. Special reports / short literature reviews on topics that appear to be getting a lot of research attention or if there has been a recent shift in the thinking or theory
  6. The ability to request a watch list for new research in keyword areas (as long as it is within the realms of:
    1. Leadership
    2. Management
    3. Human resources (not legal aspects)
    4. Organisational development
    5. Organisational change
    6. Organisational learning
    7. Learning and development,
    8. Coaching
    9. Work Psychology
    10. Decision making
  7. Request specific research / brief literature reviews
  8. Access to the entire archive of previous research briefings, copies of the Oxford Review, infographics, video research briefings and special reports.
  9. Access to Live Reports – continually updated as new research on the topic is released
  10. Members only podcasts – research briefings in audio – coming soon
  11. Live continually updated reports


Be the most up-to-date person in the room

Apply to join now

Be impressively well informed

Get the very latest research intelligence briefings, video research briefings, infographics and more sent direct to you as they are published

Be the most impressively well-informed and up-to-date person around...

Powered by ConvertKit
Like what you see? Help us spread the word